Thanksgiving Leftovers: How Long They Last and How to Store Them

Thanksgiving leftovers are good for 3 to 4 days in the fridge, as long as they went in within 2 hours of the meal. That covers leftover turkey, stuffing, gravy and most side dishes. The USDA puts it simply: eat them by the Monday after Thanksgiving, or freeze them. Frozen leftovers stay safe for as long as they stay frozen; the freezer times below are about taste.

The short version: refrigerate everything within 2 hours (1 hour if it's above 90°F, or 32°C). Carve the turkey off the bone and pack food in shallow containers. Eat leftovers within 3 to 4 days, or freeze them. Reheat to 165°F (74°C) and bring gravy to a rolling boil. Homemade cranberry sauce and fruit pie last longer; cream pies don't.

Where these times come from

Every time in this post comes from a US government source:

Fridge times assume a fridge at 40°F (4°C) or below. Freezer times assume 0°F (-18°C) or below.

How long each Thanksgiving dish lasts

DishFridgeFreezer
Turkey, sliced or in pieces3 to 4 days4 months
Turkey covered in broth or gravy3 to 4 days6 months
Stuffing, cooked3 to 4 days4 to 6 months
Gravy3 to 4 days2 to 3 months
Mashed potatoes, cooked vegetables3 to 4 days1 to 2 months
Casserole with eggs, baked3 to 4 days2 to 3 months
Cranberry sauce, homemade7 to 10 daysNot recommended
Cranberry sauce, canned, opened1 to 2 weeksNot recommended
Pumpkin or pecan pie3 to 4 days1 to 2 months
Fruit pie (apple, cherry)1 week8 months
Cream pie3 to 4 daysNot recommended

A few notes on the table:

For foods that aren't on the Thanksgiving table, our food expiration dates chart covers meat, dairy, produce and pantry staples.

Get it in the fridge within 2 hours

The 2-hour rule is the one that matters most. FSIS calls the range between 40°F and 140°F (4°C and 60°C) the Danger Zone, where bacteria multiply quickly, and says perishable food shouldn't sit at room temperature for more than 2 hours. On a hot day above 90°F (32°C), that drops to 1 hour.

That clock starts when the food comes out of the oven, not when dinner ends. If the turkey came out at 2:00 and you ate at 3:00, it needs to be in the fridge by about 4:00. Anything left out longer, the USDA says to throw away.

A simple way to make this easy: clear a shelf in the fridge and set out containers before you sit down to eat. Then packing up takes ten minutes instead of feeling like a second meal to cook.

How to cool and pack Thanksgiving leftovers

The goal is to get food cold fast. A deep pot of mashed potatoes or a whole turkey stays warm in the middle for a long time, even in the fridge.

  1. Carve the turkey off the bone. FSIS advises cutting the turkey into smaller pieces: slice the breast meat, and leave the legs and wings whole. Smaller pieces cool faster than a whole bird, and the USDA doesn't recommend reheating a whole turkey anyway.
  2. Take the stuffing out of the bird. If you cooked stuffing inside the turkey, scoop it all out and refrigerate it separately.
  3. Use shallow containers. FSIS recommends dividing big amounts into shallow containers so they cool quickly. Split the potatoes, gravy and vegetables into a few smaller dishes rather than one deep one.
  4. Cover everything well. Lids, airtight wrap or sealed containers keep bacteria out, keep moisture in, and stop the stuffing from tasting like the onions next to it.
  5. Put it straight in. FSIS says hot food can go directly into the fridge. You don't need to let it cool on the counter first.

Pack in meal-sized portions while you're at it: a container of turkey with a scoop of stuffing and gravy is a lunch you can grab, and a smaller container is easier to freeze.

How to reheat leftovers safely

Reheat leftovers until they reach 165°F (74°C), measured with a food thermometer. A few tips, mostly from the FSIS leftovers guide:

Freezing and thawing Thanksgiving leftovers

If you won't finish something by the Monday after Thanksgiving, freeze it, the sooner the better. The USDA's freezing guide notes that food frozen at peak quality tastes better after thawing, and says to freeze leftovers within 3 to 4 days.

Freezing tips:

Thawing: FSIS lists three safe ways to thaw leftovers: in the fridge, in cold water, or in the microwave. Never on the counter.

You can also reheat frozen leftovers without thawing them first, FSIS says, in a saucepan, oven or microwave. It just takes longer. And if you thaw a big container in the fridge and only need part of it, the rest can go back in the freezer without reheating.

A freezer full of turkey bags is only useful if you remember them. Our freezer inventory guide shows how to keep a list so January's dinners actually happen.

A simple Thanksgiving leftover plan

A few habits keep the leftovers from turning into a fridge full of mystery containers by Tuesday.

  1. Label and date everything. A strip of masking tape and a marker: "Turkey, Thu" is enough. Without a date, nobody knows if it's day 2 or day 5.
  2. Make an eat-first shelf. Put all the Thanksgiving leftovers on one shelf at eye level, in front of everything else, so they get eaten before anything new gets opened.
  3. Plan the next three days. Turkey sandwiches on Friday, a turkey and stuffing bake on Saturday, soup from the leftover meat on Sunday.
  4. Freeze on day 3. On Saturday or Sunday, look at what's left and freeze anything you won't finish by Monday. Freezing before the time runs out beats throwing it out after.
  5. Monday is the last day. Anything in the fridge that hasn't been eaten or frozen by Monday goes in the bin.
  6. Don't cook too much next year. Note what was left over. If you threw out half the green beans, make less next time.

For more habits that cut waste year round, see how to reduce food waste at home.

Track your leftovers with Panzy

Panzy is a pantry inventory app for iPhone, and it's good at exactly this: food without a printed date that you need to eat by a certain day.

Panzy's item screen for Leftover Chili, 3 portions, with an Add Date of Nov 1, an Expiry Date of Nov 5, 2 days remaining, an Expiring Soon label and the location Refrigerator
Give each leftover the 3 to 4 day fridge time as its expiry date, and Panzy counts down the days for you.
Panzy's item form with an expiry date, the Expiry Reminder switch turned on and Reminder Timing set to 2 days before expiry
With Panzy+, get a reminder a day or two before the date, in time to eat it or freeze it.
Panzy's Freezer list showing chicken breast, frozen peas, ground beef, chicken soup and salmon fillets, each with a quantity and how many months until it expires
Frozen leftovers get their own list with the freezer time as the date, so nothing gets lost at the back.

The free version tracks up to 50 items, with ads, which is plenty for a holiday's worth of leftovers. Panzy+ adds unlimited items, expiry reminders, the automatic shopping list, iCloud sync across your Apple devices, and no ads.

Panzy: pantry tracker

Track what's in your pantry, fridge and freezer, see what is expiring soon, and keep a shopping list that knows what you're low on. Free for up to 50 items.

Download on the App Store

Common questions

How long does leftover turkey last?

Cooked turkey lasts 3 to 4 days in the fridge, according to FSIS. In the freezer, plain sliced turkey keeps its best quality for about 4 months, or 6 months if it's covered in broth or gravy. Refrigerate it within 2 hours of cooking, cut off the bone.

Can you eat Thanksgiving leftovers after 5 days?

The USDA says no: use or freeze leftovers within four days of when you first cooked them, which means by the Monday after Thanksgiving.

Can you freeze mashed potatoes and stuffing?

Yes. Cooked stuffing keeps 4 to 6 months frozen according to FSIS, and mashed potatoes about 1 to 2 months for best quality according to the FoodKeeper. Freeze them in small, flat portions and reheat to 165°F (74°C).

Can you refreeze leftovers?

Yes, in two cases, FSIS says. Leftovers thawed in the fridge can go back in the freezer without reheating, and any leftovers reheated to 165°F (74°C) can be refrozen. Food thawed in cold water should be cooked before refreezing. Don't refreeze anything that sat out more than 2 hours.

Does pumpkin pie need to be refrigerated?

Yes. The FoodKeeper limits pumpkin and pecan pies to 2 hours at room temperature, then 3 to 4 days in the fridge. Fruit pies like apple can stay on the counter for 1 to 2 days.